NYC Dining: Dirt Candy

Dirt Candy
430 E. 9th Street, New York, NY 10009
(212) 228-7732

Web Site:

Since changing my dietary habits I’ve started to eat a lot more vegetarian cuisine, or food that incorporates a lot more vegetable content in it. However, I’ve never considered myself a vegetarian or God forbid, a Vegan.

Still, some chefs are talented enough to do marvelous and highly creative things with vegetables. They are few and far between, but they do exist. One of these chefs is Natural Gourmet Institute graduate Amanda Cohen, formerly the Chef de Cuisine at Pure Food and Wine, considered to be among the city’s best vegetarian restaurants, as well as at the late Heirloom (closed in 2006) which was highly regarded for its vegetarian cuisine.  Chef Cohen has paired herself with the talents of Pastry Chef Debbie Lee, who hails from P*ONG (Pastry Chef Pichet Ong’s restaurant in Greenwich Village) as well as Pure Food and Wine,  where she worked with Amanda.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

The tiny storefront of Dirt Candy, in Manhattan’s East Village, close to Tompkins Square Park.

Click on the “Read the rest of this entry” link below for more.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Dirt Candy’s tiny main dining room, which has seating capacity for about 24. The entire restaurant, including its tables, chairs and all the design elements are made of  recycled materials.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Chef Amanda at her little prep station which faces the main dining room.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

The seasonal menu.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

While the dining room is indeed very small and tight quarters, the effect is a very cozy and welcoming atmosphere.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

The bread was a nice foccacia with herb infused olive oil.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

We ordered two wines, a Spanish Cava Brut Rose (girly wine!)  sparkling red as well as a German Sylvaner, which had a nice acidity to it.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Jalapeno Hush Puppies served with maple butter. Everybody loved these, and the Jalapenos added just the right amount of heat to go with the sweetness of the maple syrup butter.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Spinach Soup with Smoked Tofu Dumplings lemon confit, water chestnuts and pistachio oil. While indeed a striking looking soup, I thought something was missing from this. Without having a bit of confit with each spoonful I thought it was underseasoned and the concentrated spinach favor resulted in an unpleasant bitter aftertaste I didn’t like.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

A wider view of the dining room.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Greek Salad trumpet royale mushrooms and preserved lemon mayo. This was an Israeli-style Mediterranean salad, with lots of olives (which I love) a sharp Feta cheese and wonderful breaded fried trumpet mushrooms on top, meant to be an analogue to Calamari Rings. At first we thought they were actually Onion Rings — even until this morning, when the chef corrected me on it. We adored this dish.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Portobello Mousse,  fennel,  with pear compote. Here mushrooms were given a textural treatment to make them behave like Pate de Foie Gras, and it was definitely successful. A vegetarian charcuterie, if you will.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Chef Amanda beaming over her lovely dishes.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Mixed Greens with Grilled Cheese Croutons, roasted garlic vinaigrette and candied grapefruit pops. The grapefruit slices were treated like candy apples and had a nice candy shell on them. Each crouton was actually a miniature grilled cheese sandwich, which we all thought was cute. There’s definitely a lot of whimsy in Amanda’s food.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Crispy Tofu with Green Ragout and kaffir lime beurre blanc. I typically don’t like tofu as a focus dish, I prefer it to pick up flavors from meat and sauce, and use it as a protein extender with traditional Asian-style dishes such as a Sichuan Ma Po Tofu or Korean Soondubu Jigae. Still, using the seared tofu block with the crispy skin over the rich vegetable base as a fish analogue worked very well.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

The kitchen itself is very tight quarters, there’s only one Sous Chef on the line here besides Amanda.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Stone Ground Grits with pickled shitakes and a tempura poached egg. This was one of my favorite dishes of the entire evening, I loved the richness of the grits/polenta with the ricotta cheese and the runny egg.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Carrot Risotto carrot drops and carrot curls. We were all in agreement that this was the most successful dish of the evening. This was a perfectly implemented risotto cooked in carrot juices, giving it an intense carrot flavor. The carrot pieces are actually coins of home made carrot pasta meant to look like sliced carrots.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Pinot Grigio Papardelle roasted cauliflower and pine nuts.

I really liked the pasta sauce, which had a great acidic flavor and punch from the wine, and the roasted cauliflower with the pine nuts was an excellent combination. However the pasta itself was fairly pedestrian, I think the dish needed a heartier pasta, perhaps a gnocchi or a wider/thicker noodle ribbon with a texture.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Dessert Menu

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Popcorn Pudding with hazelnut caramel corn. I really liked this dessert, like a popcorn/Cracker Jack Pot au Creme.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Sesame Caramel Cake citrus salad, grapefruit sorbet. Intense grapefruit sorbet with fresh citrus fruit over a sesame cake. This was Rachel’s favorite.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Ricotta Fritters green tomato marmalade, lemon olive oil ice cream. These guys went really fast.

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Chocolate Cake chocolate chili ice cream, sweet potato sorbet. I’m a chocolate freak, so naturally this dessert was my favorite. Super intense dark chocolate ice cream, which a perfect warm brownie with a nice crust and semi-molten chocolate cake on the inside. What’s not to like?

Dirt Candy, Greenwich Village, NYC by you.

Coffee and Tea was served in individual Bodum thermal press pots. This was a thoughtful presentation considering it’s wintertime and it’s nice to have the beverage stay hot.

10 Responses to NYC Dining: Dirt Candy

  1. Robert says:

    I don’t know how the food tastes, but it looks ridicoulas.

    Why is it that chefs that work sans-meat tend to be way over the top in their presentation?

  2. […] meat-inclined blog to have been won over by the wiles of Dirt Candy and chef/owner Amanda Cohen; Off the Broiler has discovered the vegetarian charms of the place, too. Jason Perlow hits on all the likely things […]

  3. bethy1810 says:

    Beautiful photographs! As someone who doesn’t like vegetables as a rule, I usually have to challenge my in-house “chef” (aka my husband) to make veggies in a way that I’ll like, and I appreciate any restaurant that attempts the same thing.

  4. penangtuapui says:

    Wow, you photo of the food is really nice. I had difficult to find the vegetarian food in Chandler.
    Nice blog.

  5. organicgal says:

    Robert, not all veg chefs are into this level of presentation. Candle Cafe has fairly simple presentation on most items. It depends on the “style” of the joint. I’m not a veg (though I play one on tv :) ) but I mostly eat veg and am always looking for restaurants that 1) have decent veg and 2) know what to do with them. I want to try this one out. I think I won’t like it (too wacky flavor profiles for this simple woman) but I’m open to be pleasantly surprised and as we all know…even fried shoes probably taste good!

  6. Andrew says:

    You should be there when the switch for the disco lights accidentally gets flicked and it takes a little while to figure out how to turn it off (as it did on Saturday evening when I was there)! The food was amazing and your pictures definitely look a lot better than mine.

  7. Andy Deer - Los Angeles, CA says:

    Response to Robert – Dining is about all five senses. Presentation is very important. I guess you have not been to WD-50 or a ton of other NYC meat restaurants that are “way over the top in presentation.”
    Congratulations Amanda!

  8. Carol says:

    The food was amazing, the carrot risotto especially, As Andrew mentioned, we too got to see the light show, and that was very cool. My personal favorite was the popcorn pudding, (just when you think it can’t get better!) And Ms. Cohen’s service was FABULOUS.

  9. Patricia says:

    I was so very disappointed with this place. There was no honor placed upon these veggies, rather, expected bland existences were presented in humble place settings.

  10. The photos had my mouth watering that I made a reservation the same day. The food is as good as it looks so for anyone that likes how it looks — go taste it!! thanks for the recomendation!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: